“Once you close your hospitals in a rural community…you might as well take those roads, plow them up and plant pine trees.” Those are the words of a state legislator in Georgia, where, perhaps more than any other state, hospitals are in crisis, in large part because state leaders have refused to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act.
Access to health care, like health itself, tends to be taken for granted until it’s taken away. And just as there is far more to a person than their health, there is far more to a hospital than the day-to-day provision of health care. The loss of health has a ripple effect that spreads beyond the sick individual to family members, employers, coworkers, business partners, educators and beyond.
The same applies to hospitals. The news story where the Georgia legislator was quoted laid out just what any hospital means to its community and region: “Hospitals provide not only critical health care for communities but serve as a core economic engine as well. They are often one of the biggest and best-paying employers in a community. They also can be vital in helping to attract new companies — and new tax dollars — to (the state).
“But the closing of a rural hospital can be the nail in the coffin for potential deals to bring in new manufacturers. If someone gets injured using a buzz saw while cutting timber, access to immediate emergency care is a must…When a hospital closes, the pharmacies suffer, the florists suffer, the convenience stores suffer.”
None of this is news to Iowa hospitals and IHA, which regularly (and necessarily) remind the public, media and government leaders of hospitals’ huge economic impact in Iowa, now worth more than $4.1 billion and directly employing more than 71,000 people. When that ripple effect is added in and those Hy-Vee florists and Casey’s clerks are considered, hospitals become responsible for nearly 120,000 jobs and more than $6 billion in economic activity.
Overall, health care is now a $14 billion industry in Iowa that is connected to more than 300,000 jobs (about 20 percent of the state’s non-farm employment). Compare that to, say, casinos, which tend to get far more attention and credit as supposed economic boosters but only provide the state with about 16,000 jobs worth $2.5 billion.
Furthermore, those casino jobs are very isolated around the state, have little need for highly-educated workers and hardly any potential for individual career growth. Iowa hospitals, on the other hand, need thousands of workers with college degrees and advanced technical training. In the same vein, the opportunities for career building are evidenced by the many hospital leaders who started in entry-level jobs and stayed on to become unit managers, department directors, chief nurses, vice presidents, COOs and CEOs – all at the same hospital.
But the impact goes even further than money, jobs and careers. Perhaps more than any other Iowa industry, health care (and particularly hospitals) attracts and retains young workers and their young families. This group is where local volunteers and community leaders are found and cultivated. This is the group that sustains communities economically and socially while providing the most potential for the future.
In Iowa hospitals, that potential is spread across the state, literally from border to border. In this way, hospitals are Iowa’s hope for not only attaining optimal individual health, but keeping the road open for widespread economic security and growth.
This time of year holds a special place in my heart. Having been raised on a century farm, I know that getting the crop out becomes the center of discussion not long after school starts in the fall. It’s talk about the moisture content, the lines at the local elevator and, of course, yields and grain prices.
In late October I had the pleasure of seeing the harvest first-hand again. On an absolutely perfect fall day, warm enough that just a light jacket sufficed, I drove my 89-year-old father in his beloved Cadillac out to a field he had farmed for decades. He told me, as he has each time we’ve driven by this field, about what a great piece of ground it was. I pulled the car onto the shoulder of the road so we’d be strategically positioned to watch the combine.
It truly was a perfect day. The sky was bright blue without a cloud providing a great contrast to the natural browns of the standing corn stalks and the grass in the ditch that was still bright green. We rolled the windows down and took it all in – the hum of the combine as it moved in a smooth cadence towards us, the cloud of chaff following it and the stream of yellow as the corn poured into the grain wagon. It was so peaceful, you couldn’t help but feel a sense of balance as well as gratitude and happiness.
Little did I know at the time, but that weekend would be my last with my dad. I’m so grateful for that day and so grateful that as his time with us was about to end, I did not have to guess as to his wishes. We had the conversations so we knew his priorities, what he valued most, and those goals were clearly understood by his doctor, nurses and caregivers.
It’s encouraging to see new efforts are underway to support these conversations. As a nation, we have hopefully moved beyond the reactionary words from previous political posturing that derailed this work five years ago. Bills have been introduced in both the U.S. Senate and House in support of advance care planning: S. 2240, the Medicare Choices Empowerment and Protection Act and HR 1173, the Personalize Your Care Act of 2013.
And Medicare may soon begin following what some private payers and two state Medicaid programs are already doing – reimbursing physicians for having end-of-life discussions with patients. The American Medical Association has created billing codes for advance care planning services and submitted them to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. If Medicare approves the codes, it will further broaden advance care planning as more private payers will likely follow suit and reimburse physicians for engaging their patients in these critical conversations.
Respected physician and talented journalist Dr. Atul Gawande is also entering this space. In his latest book, “Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End,” Dr. Gawande uses research and storytelling to demonstrate how medicine can be compatible with providing meaningful life and not just extending it. Better end-of-life care conversations between clinicians and patients can provide patients with a full and dignified life until the end.
These conversations are still not happening often enough and to that end clinicians, social workers and clergy are seeking training. “Respecting Choices” is a model used across the country and Iowa to assist patients and families in making informed end-of-life decisions. Early next year, Respecting Choices facilitator certification will be offered at IHA thru the Hospice and Palliative Care Association of Iowa, enabling a new crop of trainers to help patients and families facing a serious illness to plan the life they want, all the way to the end.
This was my dad’s final harvest and I’m thankful that it was bountiful in meaningful ways. We knew his priorities and his wishes and were able to honor what he valued.
During the first six months of this year, the number of people hospitalized in Iowa without insurance fell by 45.7 percent compared with the same period last year, an IHA analysis has found. The analysis is based on data collected from 101 Iowa hospitals from January through June.
According to the study, out of about 159,000 hospital discharges from January to June in 2014 and 2013, 4,445 patients were uninsured this year compared with 8,181 in 2013.
The reductions are linked to the state’s expansion of Medicaid through the Iowa Health and Wellness Plan, which has helped thousands of low-income Iowans gain health insurance coverage. Because of Medicaid expansion, in a six-month span, Iowa hospitals cared for fewer uninsured patients in all settings, including patients admitted for inpatient care as well as those seeking care at hospital emergency rooms and at outpatient clinics. Similar results are being seen in other states that expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act.
IHA President and CEO Kirk Norris said, “This analysis provides further evidence that Medicaid expansion is doing what it was intended to do – making health care more accessible and affordable for the 110,000 Iowans who have gained eligibility and coverage.”
For the period January 1-June 30, overall inpatient admissions at Iowa hospitals declined 4.4 percent compared with the same period in 2013. Within that decline, the number of uninsured hospitalized patients with no source of payment for their health care fell by 45.7 percent in 2014.
Additionally, fears that expanding coverage would make care so easily accessible that use of hospital emergency rooms would rise to unprecedented levels have not materialized, the IHA analysis found. Total visits to emergency rooms increased less than 1 percent when comparing the six-month spans in 2013 and 2014, despite approximately 30,000 patients with new policies purchased through the Health Insurance Marketplace.
With more Iowans now insured, hospitals’ charity care losses fell 18.5 percent, yielding a total six-month improvement of $32.5 million.
“Our health care system works best for those who are insured,” Norris said. “Coverage does more than help pay medical bills, it brings people into the system. It helps them establish a relationship with a personal physician and create a medical home from where care can be managed and coordinated with other providers.”
They know less than they think they know. That’s the finding of a recent study that evaluated people’s confidence about choosing and using health insurance compared with their actual knowledge and skills.
As people shop for health coverage this fall, the gap between perception and reality could lead them to choose plans that don’t meet their needs, the researchers suggest.
“There’s a concern that people who don’t have much experience with health insurance don’t protect themselves financially, and then something happens,” says Kathryn Paez, a principal researcher at the American Institutes for Research who co-authored the study. “So they’re learning through hard knocks.”
The nationally representative survey of 828 people aged 22 to 64 is part of a project to develop a standardized questionnaire that researchers, health plans and providers can use to assess people’s health insurance literacy.
The study found, for example, that while three-quarters of Americans say they’re confident they know how to use health insurance, only 20 percent could correctly calculate how much they would owe for a routine physician visit. Many people don’t understand commonly used terms such as “out-of-pocket costs,” “HMO” and “PPO,” according to the study.
The study also found that certain groups of people tended to have a tougher time using health insurance, including young people, minorities, those with lower income or educational levels and those who used health care services infrequently.
People who visit the doctor occasionally but have never been hospitalized or visited the emergency room may be overconfident they understand how health insurance works, says Paez. Likewise, people who belong to integrated health care systems where providers are generally on staff may not realize the potential complications of in-network and out-of-network coverage, among other things, she says.
More comprehensive education could help close the gap between what people think they know about health insurance and what they actually know. In the meantime, the issue brief about the study includes a consumer checklist to aid consumers in choosing a plan.
The Affordable Care Act has now been in place and functioning for a year and many are wondering, is the law fulfilling its core goals? The New York Times recently provided an expanded analysis of the law and generally concluded the law is succeeding, though more time is needed to know for certain. Here is a summary of the Times’ findings:
The main goal of the Affordable Care Act was to reduce the number of Americans without health insurance. Since the law was enacted, the percentage of uninsured Americans has decreased by about 25 percent within one year, or approximately eight to 11 million people. Much of this is because of state Medicaid expansion, with at least as many people enrolled in Medicaid as have signed up for private insurances. Although the Affordable Care Act will never bring universal health insurance coverage, it hopes to continue closing the gap and over the next four years it is projected to expand coverage to millions more Americans.
For millions of Americans, the Affordable Care Act has provided access to comprehensive coverage at an affordable price. Of the 7.3 million people who signed up for private insurance through online exchanges, 85 percent qualified for government subsidies to reduce the cost of premiums. Although the law has made insurance affordable for some, it has also created high deductibles and out-of-pocket expenses for others, and has caused premiums to raise for some who already had insurance or were not eligible for subsidies. Additionally, while trying to keep costs down, insurers may be too restrictive about allowing consumers to use doctors outside of the company’s network. With wide variations in pricing between states, it is difficult to know who will find plans unaffordable, but evidence suggests middle-income people who don’t qualify for subsidies will struggle the most with health insurance costs. A 4 percent median premium increase is expected for 2015, so consumers will need to shop around for the lowest prices.
Currently, there is not enough data on the entire population to determine whether the law is improving the nation’s overall health. Some early data does suggest that the law is having a positive impact on young people. Because the law permits young Americans to remain on their parent’s insurance plans until reaching the age of 26, the share of 19-to-25-year-olds without health insurance declined to 21 percent in the first quarter of the year, a reduction of about four million people. Outside the young adult group, there were very little changes in a variety of health measures, such as the number of flu shots received or whether people had a regular place to go for medical care. However, preventative screenings, especially for colon cancer, have increased 8 percent since 2010. More time is needed to determine if the law will positively impact the nation’s health in the long run.
Financial Stability for Providers and Insurers
Both Wall Street analysts and health care experts say the Affordable Care Act has helped the health care industry financially. The insurance industry has seen the greatest benefits thus far, because of new customers and growth in demand for private insurance. The number of insurers participating in the online health exchanges is also expected to increase in 2015, an indicator of the profitability of the marketplace and the business the law has created. The law also brought new paying patients to hospitals and new prescription users to the pharmaceutical industry. Although hospitals are being hurt by a provision of the law that cuts their Medicare payments by $260 billion over 10 years, they are estimated to save $5-7 billion in uncompensated care costs this year because more people have insurance, according to the Department of Health and Human Services. Iowa hospitals have seen a significant decrease in charity care over the last year.
The expansion of Medicaid, the government health care program for low-income citizens, is a crucial part of the Affordable Care Act. Medicaid expansion is optional for all states and 27 states and the District of Columbia (as well as Iowa) have expanded. These states, including Iowa, have seen a significant reduction in uninsured people, while states without expanded Medicaid are seeing a coverage gap in health insurance for people who earn too much to receive Medicaid, but too little to receive federal subsidies to reduce premiums. Pressure from hospitals that can get federal funds from Medicaid expansion has caused some states to consider expansion. Federal officials say 8.7 million people have been added to Medicaid rolls since last October; however, with so many new people in the expanded program, there are growing concerns with the shortage of doctors.
Controlling Health Care Spending
While the Affordable Care Act was intended to slow down health care spending, the amount of money being spent on health care had begun slowing even before the law was put in place. There has been a significant slowdown in the growth of health spending, due to the recession, higher-deductible policies that discourage people from seeking health care, a decline in the development of new and costly prescription drugs and the reduction of unneeded care. In the short term, the law could actually increase health care spending because of the expansion of health insurance to millions of Americans. The real test of the Affordable Care Act will be whether or not the declined spending continues, even with the amount of new insured people in the system.